The Anti-LHD Folks, We will Scare you with Lies
May 4th, 2012This next number in the Newburyport Local Historic District (LHD) musical, “LHD-Bombshell,” (working title, see earlier posts), I think I’m going to call, “We will scare you, no matter what it takes.”
The scene opens with a row of 5 doors, set diagonally across the side of the stage. The doors are all painted different colors. And then, I think there would be 5 women all dressed the same, with the same wig, a piece of paper in hand.
Lights go up on the 5 doors and the 5 women march as if they are going door to door, and they line up in front of the five doors and knock, maybe pound on the doors and then stand back.
And then in unison the 5 doors open.
The musical number begins. The five women launch into song, “We will scare you about LHD, no matter what it takes.”
The first one sings, “Your home insurance premiums will go through the roof with LHD.”
The second one sings, “A board of appointed experts (who don’t even live here) will control your life.”
The third one sings, “With LHD you will be lost in litigation.”
The fourth one sings, “You’ll never be able to do anything ever to your house.”
The fifth one sings, “The LHD gestapo will make you pay fines, fines, fines.”
Mark Twain
And on the other side of the stage, historic preservationists, sitting on the edge of the stage, others standing behind them sing, “It’s not true, it’s a lie, don’t believe them, don’t believe them, they are lying.”
And, I debated how to do this again, but I think I’m going with Mark Twain one more time, even though the quote is not attributed to him. Everyone stops singing, lights go dim, the Mark Twain character walks on stage, center stage, spotlight on him, turns to the audience and says, not sings, “A lie told often enough becomes the truth” (the old proof by repeated assertion technique).
The stage goes dark.
And yes, the lies, misinformation, omission of the facts about Newburyport’s proposed Local Historic District (LHD) is off the charts, and “proof by repeated assertion,” what a way to lose Newburyport’s historic assets. Oy Vey.
Proof by assertion: “Proof by assertion, sometimes informally referred to as proof by repeated assertion, is a logical fallacy (a statement or an argument based on a false or invalid inference) in which a proposition is repeatedly restated regardless of contradiction. Sometimes this may be repeated until challenges dry up, at which point it is asserted as fact due to its not being contradicted (argumentum ad nauseam).”
You can read the entire explanation of what “proof by repeated assertion” is here.